CHAFFEE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING
April 29, 2009 1:00 pm Steam Plant Theater, Salida, CO MAP
Continuation of the April 21, 2009 public hearing regarding the request from Nestle Waters North America, Inc. - Special Land Use Permit (SLUP) and 1041 Permit. The request is the development of spring water harvesting in the Ruby Mountain area near Nathrop, associated five-mile transmission pipeline, and loading facility in Johnson Village. Additional information can be obtained on the Chaffee County website - www.chaffeecounty.org
1:00 pm Continuation of Public Testimony If public testimony for those in attendance is completed, break until 6:00 pm
6:00 pm Further Public Testimony for anyone who could not make the 1:00 pm session
How to Prepare for the Meeting: How to Contact the Commissioners:
1. Carpool if possible firstname.lastname@example.org
2. The Hall holds a limited number of people, email@example.com
so if possible be there early to get a good seat. firstname.lastname@example.org
3. If you want to speak (greatly encouraged) be sure to find the
signup sheet that should be on a table near the front. The sign Contact these Commissioners by email to let them
up sheet from April 21 will NOT be used. know your thoughts and concerns with the Nestle
proposal. For points you might consider
Some of the unresolved issues pertaining to the 1041 permit are:
1) Legal Liability
-What if the springs are damaged?
-Cost of future monitoring and/or legal action for enforcement
2) Heavy Truck Traffic on Hwy 285
-Winding steep mountain highway, icy 6 months of the year
-25 trucks a day, each way, will impact everyone that uses Highway 285.
-Higher emergency response expenses -Higher road repair and maintenance costs
3) Water augmentation
-Replacement water is augmented from Aurora for ten years. What then?
-Will Nestle “Buy and Dry” land in the valley?
- Baseline data has NOT been gathered. Data must be gathered over a full years cycle. Good science says several years.
- Monitoring can NOT begin before baseline data obtained, Pumping cannot begin before baseline data obtained.
-Cone of depression affects wetlands around the spring.
-Recharge to aquifer relies on precipitation, irrigation, and runoff from Mosquito Mountains east of Arkansas River
-Effects of future droughts
-Nestle claims drought resistant spring. How can they support that?
- Pump tests are only 3 days long, not nearly long enough
- Pump tests must be done at different seasons of the year
6) Economics -No jobs -No revenues -Minimal taxes
7) The issue of diverting native water
-Where could this go?
-Where will it end?
- Do we want to support the privatization of a vital natural resource by for-profit companies?
8) What’s the rush?
-Commissioners should not be pressured by Nestle to grant the permit without the full review process.
9) Recreational Tourism - how will it be affected? Chaffee County gets 250,000 rafters on the river each summer, that
is roughly 37 million dollars. 3% decrease due to traffic? = 1.25 million $$$$ LOST. ????Skiers each winter = more
$$$$ LOST (Semi-Tanker Trucks will run 365 days/year)
Ideas To Consider:
Sustainability requires local foods, alternative energies, affordable housing, good schools, protecting ranching, and maintaining native waters. Nestle claims this is a sustainable project. What is sustainable about a project that uses on an annual basis: 150,000 kw/hours of coal-fired electricity to pump the water, then 613,200 gallons of diesel fuel to haul it to Denver-plus more energy for bottling/distribution, then puts 1.2 million non-recycled plastic bottles into landfills, road ditches, and waterways per day--or 438 million per year?
Tips for writing/testifying:
The goal of your testimony should be to directly address the 1041 Application, as well as provide your opinions and concerns as residents of the County. Tell the commissioners why you are there, what your concerns are, and why you have those opinions.
ANY 1041 application should be guided by the following principles:
(a) To promote the health, safety, and general welfare of the citizens of Chaffee County;
(b) To encourage and strength the established industries of agriculture, mining, tourism, recreation and education;
(c) To plan for adequate transportation, water, wastewater treatment, electricity, telephone,schools
parks and other similar facilities, and to provide for the phased development of such services and facilities;
(d) To protect the beauty of the landscape and the rural character of the County, to enhance recreational opportunities for residents and visitors, to preserve important archeological and historic sites and significant wildlife habitat, to protect air and water quality, and to conserve soil, water and forestry resources;
(e) To protect and enhance the economic strength of the private and governmental sectors of the County;
(f) To regulate development projects that would otherwise cause excessive noise, water, and/or air pollution, or which would otherwise degrade or threaten the existing environmental quality within the County; and
(g) To ensure, to the maximun extent practicable, that growth will pay for itself, and to ensure that the present residents do not have to subsidize new growth and development through increased taxes and / or degradation of their existing quality of life.